The Princess of Wales, Kate Middleton, is doing well six months after announcing her battle with an unidentified form of cancer. On September 9th, she shared an emotional video revealing that she had completed preventative chemotherapy and was now focusing on remaining cancer-free.

This candid announcement was met with a range of responses from the public, with many praising her bravery while others questioned the tone of the message given her privileged position as a royal.

In the video, Middleton spoke about the challenges of dealing with cancer, describing the experience as “complex, frightening, and unpredictable.” She expressed how facing her illness brought her closer to her vulnerabilities and gave her a new perspective on life. Celebrities like actress Olivia Munn, who has also battled breast cancer, offered their support, calling Kate’s words inspiring and relatable.

Many social media users echoed this sentiment, sharing their own stories of illness and appreciating the Princess’s courage in addressing her health journey so openly.

However, not everyone found the video resonating in the same way. Some criticized it, arguing that it felt out of touch with the realities faced by everyday people dealing with cancer, who often lack access to the same medical resources, financial stability, and support networks. One commenter on X (formerly Twitter) mentioned that the video might have been insensitive to those who don’t have the same advantages, such as top-tier doctors or help with everyday tasks like child care. Another suggested that a simple written statement would have sufficed.

David Maau, a counselor who works with cancer patients, noted that reactions to high-profile figures discussing their health can be mixed. While celebrities like Kate Middleton have more resources, it can still be important for them to share their stories to inspire others going through similar challenges. Maau emphasized that sharing vulnerabilities can humanize even the most well-known public figures, helping others feel less alone.

Despite the intention behind Middleton’s video, some pointed out that her experience with cancer is quite different from that of the average person, particularly when it comes to the financial strain of treatment. For many families, cancer diagnosis leads to significant financial hardships due to medical expenses, loss of income, and other costs that aren’t covered by insurance. A recent survey by the Canadian Cancer Society found that 90% of Canadians believe a sudden cancer diagnosis would negatively impact their family’s finances, with 30% saying they might have to go into debt to cover medical expenses. These stresses, combined with the emotional toll of cancer, are challenges that most people face without the same level of support the Royals enjoy.

While the Royal Family has access to top-tier medical care through both the UK’s National Health Service (NHS) and private healthcare options, their experiences with hospitals are not the same as those of the general public. For example, Kate Middleton received treatment at the London Clinic, a private hospital, where she underwent abdominal surgery in January 2024. Similarly, King Charles has also been treated at the same clinic for health issues, including an enlarged prostate and an undisclosed form of cancer. These factors make it difficult for some to relate to the Royals’ health challenges.

Although Middleton’s video was intended as a message of solidarity with other cancer patients, her circumstances differ significantly from non-royals. Still, for many, her openness about her health journey was a source of hope and inspiration during difficult times.